Financial, Geopolitical & Citizenship Intelligence Membership

Insights · Company & Business

The Rise of Startup Ecosystems: What Makes a Hub Work

What builds a startup ecosystem, how Silicon Valley, Israel, Singapore and others differ, and the signals to watch instead of a list of company names.

The Rise of Startup Ecosystems: What Makes a Hub Work

Why a "top companies to watch" list is the wrong starting point

Lists of startups to watch date quickly. Most of the names change within a year, and a few of them fail. A more durable question is why some cities produce successful startups again and again, while others with similar talent and money do not. Understanding that makes it far easier to judge any individual company, and it is the lens investors, founders and policymakers actually use.

What an ecosystem is made of

A startup ecosystem is the set of people, institutions and money that make it easier to start and grow a company in a particular place. Researchers who rank ecosystems, including the Startup Genome project in its annual Global Startup Ecosystem Report, look at a similar set of ingredients:

  • Talent. Engineers, designers, salespeople and experienced operators who have worked in startups before. Experience of a past failure or success is as valuable as a degree.
  • Capital. Angel investors, venture capital funds, and enough follow-on funding that a good company does not have to move away to raise its next round.
  • Knowledge. Research universities and corporate labs that produce ideas, graduates and spin-offs.
  • Customers. Nearby companies, governments and consumers who will try something new and give early feedback.
  • Connections. Dense networks of founders, mentors, lawyers and accountants who know the work and speak candidly.
  • Rules and culture. Reasonable corporate law, tolerance for failure, bankruptcy rules that allow a second try, and visas that let foreign talent stay.

No single ingredient is enough. A city with great universities but no growth capital loses its best founders to cities that have both.

Examples that show different routes

EcosystemWhat built it
Silicon ValleyStanford and nearby research, semiconductor and then software industries, and the world's deepest pool of venture capital
Israel (Tel Aviv)Military technology units, strong universities and the government-backed Yozma programme of the 1990s, which seeded a venture capital industry
SingaporeStrong state support, an international financial centre, and a position as a regional base for companies expanding into Southeast Asia
India (Bengaluru and other cities)Large engineering talent base, a large domestic market and the government's Startup India initiative launched in 2016
Estonia (Tallinn)Early digital government, and the e-Residency programme (2014), which lets foreign entrepreneurs run a European company online
Africa (Lagos, Nairobi, Cape Town, Cairo)Fast-growing mobile and fintech use, young populations and growing diaspora investment, though local follow-on capital is still thin

Money moves in cycles

Venture funding is cyclical. Global venture investment surged during 2020 and 2021, then fell sharply in 2022 and 2023 as interest rates rose and investors cut back on risk. Those years showed how much depends on cheap capital: valuations dropped, many companies had to raise money on tougher terms, and some shut down. Ecosystems with a deep base of experienced investors and corporate buyers generally came through better than those that depended on a few large funds or on foreign investors.

What to watch instead of a list of names

  1. Follow-on funding. Are local startups raising second and third rounds without leaving? This shows depth.
  2. Exits. Are there acquisitions and public listings that return money to founders and early staff? They fund the next generation.
  3. Talent flow. Are experienced people moving in or out, and are foreign engineers able to get visas?
  4. Corporate demand. Do local large companies and governments buy from startups?
  5. Cost of living and office space. Hubs can price out the people who made them valuable.
  6. Policy direction. Look for tax treatment of stock options, ease of company formation and rules for foreign founders.

How to size up a single startup in any ecosystem

  • Is the problem real, and are customers paying, not only signing up?
  • How much runway does the company have, and what is its monthly burn rate?
  • Does the founding team have relevant experience and complementary skills?
  • Who are the investors, and have they backed similar companies through a downturn?
  • Is the company dependent on a single customer, supplier or platform?
  • Does it have clear legal ownership of its technology and a clean cap table?

Before dealing with an unfamiliar startup as a customer, supplier or investor, run basic checks on its legal identity and ownership. Our guides on B2B background checks and verifying a company profile online explain how.

Frequently asked questions

What is a unicorn?

A privately held startup valued at one billion US dollars or more. The term was coined by venture investor Aileen Lee in 2013. Valuations are set in funding rounds and can fall as well as rise.

Do startups need to be in a major hub?

Not always. Remote work has widened the choice, but access to investors, specialised talent and customers still gives established hubs an edge, especially for companies that need large amounts of capital.

Can governments create a startup ecosystem?

They can speed one up through funding, immigration policy and company law, as Israel and Estonia show. They cannot replace the private networks of experienced founders and investors that take years to form.

Are startup investments risky?

Yes. Most early-stage companies do not return investors' money, and the returns of the whole asset class are concentrated in a small number of big winners. Only invest what you can afford to lose.

Sources and further reading

  • Startup Genome, Global Startup Ecosystem Report (annual), on startupgenome.com.
  • Government of India, Startup India initiative, on startupindia.gov.in.
  • Republic of Estonia, e-Residency programme, on e-resident.gov.ee.
  • Dan Senor and Saul Singer, Start-up Nation: The Story of Israel's Economic Miracle (2009).

Programmes, rankings and funding levels change; check the sources above for the latest. This article is general information, not investment advice.

The information provided is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, tax, or legal advice.